Present-day modern motorcycles with high-performance engines need high-quality oils to keep the engine parts clean and well lubricated.
This article covers the following topics for you:
- detergent vs non-detergent oil – what are the right options for your motorcycle,
- the difference between detergent and non-detergent oil,
- a few frequently asked questions on the topic.
So, detergent vs non-detergent oil – What is the right option for your motorcycle?
Detergent oil contains detergents and non-detergent oil does not contain them. Most, modern motorcycles recommend the use of detergent oil.
The job of engine oil in your motorcycle is to lubricate, cool the engine, and keep the engine parts clean and free of deposits. A detergent oil is best suited for doing this and the detergent additives in the oil attract the dirt, debris, and carbon deposits and make the contaminants float so that the oil filter can remove them. The oil will last longer, perform better, and does not allow sludge formation
A non-detergent oil is used in older motorcycles, the oil becomes dirty and sludgy and has to be replaced more frequently.
II. Detergent vs non-detergent oil, what is the right option for your motorcycle?
The oil used for present-day modern motorcycles contains 10 to 20 percent additives and that includes detergent agents like amines, amides, etc.
The oil that contains detergent additives is called a detergent oil and that does not contain detergent additives is called a non-detergent oil.
Detergents present in the oil attract the impurities like dirt, debris, and carbon particles and make them float, and do not allow sludge formation. The floating contaminants are filtered off by the oil filter and circulation system. This process does not allow sludge formation and the oil change intervals become less frequent.
A study report shows that the detergent in the oil attracts the dirt, debris, and carbon particles and breaks them to prevent forming sludge or congestion in the engine. The detergents neutralize the acids formed during combustion and stop them from wearing down the engine metal parts.
A non-detergent oil allows the dirt, debris, and carbon particles to settle at the bottom, and slowly sludge is formed. The oil becomes dirty and needs to be replaced every 2000 to 3000 miles. You have to keep a watch on the oil quality and replace it as soon as you find it dirty. A non-detergent oil is normally used in an old motorcycle engine that does not have an oil filter.
Modern motorcycles perform better with detergent oils, and your motorcycle manufacturer must have recommended a suitable detergent oil for your motorcycle. Go through your owner’s manual and use the recommended detergent oil.
III. Difference between detergent and non-detergent oil
The differences between the detergent and non-detergent oil are compiled in the following table:
|No.||Detergent oil||Non-detergent oil|
|1||Contain detergent additives.||Does not contain detergent additives.|
|2||Detergents in the oil attract impurities (dirt, debris, and carbon particles), make them float, and do not allow sludge formation. The floating impurities are filtered off by the oil filter and the oil change intervals become less frequent.||A non-detergent oil allows sludge formation, the oil becomes dirty and needs frequent replacement.
Delay in replacing the oil, may cause the sludge particles to block engine passages.
|3||Performance is superior to non-detergent oil.||Performance is inferior to detergent oil.|
|4||Detergent oils are used in engines where the oil filter is mandatory.||Non-detergent oils are used in engines where the oil filter is not mandatory.|
|5||The detergent oils are normally thicker and darker compared to a non-detergent oil.|
|6||A detergent oil does not allow sludge formation and makes the contaminants float till it is filtered off by the oil filter.||Non-detergent oil allows sludge formation.|
IV. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
|1||How can I differentiate detergent oil from non-detergent oil?|
|The basic difference between a detergent and non-detergent oil is, that the detergent oil contains detergents (like amines, and amides), and non-detergent oil does not contain detergent. You can understand this by studying the labels on the box/bottle. Most, non-detergent oils display ‘non-detergent’ on their label.
Also, by default, all engine oils have detergents.
|2||What is the function of the ‘detergent’ in a detergent oil?|
|Detergents present in the oil attract the impurities (dirt, debris, carbon particles, etc.), make them float, and the floating impurities are filtered off by the oil filter. Detergents do not allow sludge formation.|
|3||Does the content of synthetic oil include detergents?|
|Fully synthetic oil by default has detergent agents in it.|
|4||Can I use non-detergent oil for my motorcycle?|
|The best advice is to use the oil recommended in the owner’s manual. However, in case of an emergency, if you have used non-detergent oil for your motorcycle, do not worry. Do a regular physical inspection of the oil and replace it with the correct detergent oil as soon as possible.|
|5||Where do you use non-detergent oil?|
|Non-detergent oil is used in older motorcycles that do not have an oil circulation system and oil filter, and small engines used for lawn mowers, chain saws, etc.|
Hopefully, this article can clear many of your doubts about detergent v/s non-detergent oils. However, always use the detergent oil recommended in your owner’s manual to keep your motorcycle engine healthy.